The European Commission released its decision on the International Skating Union eligibility rules

The European Commission released its decision on the International Skating Union eligibility rules

On 8 December 2017, the European Commission decided that the International Skating Union (ISU) rules imposing severe penalties on athletes participating in unofficial speed skating competitions breach EU antitrust law. The ISU must now change these rules. The decision could have a wider impact and affect all sport federations.

The investigation carried out by the DG Competition found out that the eligibility rules applied by the ice-skating federation were imposed despite the absence of threat to legitimate sports objectives. At the same time, those restrictions favour the own commercial interest of the ISU, disregarding the athletes and organisers of other events. The Commission stated that it prevents the creation of innovative competition formats since the organisers are unable to attract elite athletes to their new event. By limiting the development of alternative speed skating competition, it restricts the potential competition on the relevant market, to the detriment of ice-skating fans.

The ISU Eligibility rules are binding on all its members and their affiliated clubs. Because of their binding nature the Eligibility rules have the effect of coordinating the behaviour of the ISU Members. The Commission therefore concluded that those rules constitute a decision of an association of undertakings within the meaning of Article 101 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the EU.

The European Commission also sees a conflict of interest in ISU being both regulator and organiser of sport competitions. In this regard, all ISU decisions should be non-discriminatory and based on transparent criteria.

The Commission required the ISU to stop its “illegal conduct” within 90 days (i.e. by mid-March at the latest). The Commission abstained to impose a fine in this case but - if the ISU fails to comply with the Commission's decision - it would be liable for non-compliance payments of up to 5% of its average daily worldwide turnover.

When assessing the structural impact of this ruling, it seems clear that it is not the Commission’s intention to attack the Pyramidal structure of Sport or even to question the role of the federations in safeguarding the integrity, the proper conduct of sport and in guaranteeing safety and health of athletes. Moreover, the abstention from a direct financial fine shows that the EU acknowledges the different steps already taken by the ISU to change their rules.

However, the application of Art. 101 TFEU constitutes a real threat. Following the rationale of DG COMP, all international and European federations could be qualified as cartels. That interpretation is not acceptable. The Commission has applied the competition rules in a purely economic way and has not sufficiently taken into account the societal role of federations, the existing solidarity mechanisms, the investments in youth and women sport as described in Art. 165 TFEU.

Further information

Press release

COMP Commissioner Vestager’s statement

POLITICO interview with Vestager on the impact of the ruling

Thomas Bach’s speech at the EU Council on the social role of Sport (November 2017)

Recent Posts

Monthly Report Highlight - European Parliament draft kicks off debate on a stronger, fairer European Sport Model

The debate on the future of the European Sport Model (ESM) entered a decisive phase this month with the publication of the draft report by the European Parliament’s Committee on Culture and Education (CULT). Authored by rapporteur Bogdan Andrzej Zdrojewski (EPP, PL), the text will serve as Parliament’s formal position before the European Commission prepares […]

Read More
Empowering future sport leaders in Papendal

This week, the EOC EU Office joined forces with its partner organisations engaged at the joint NILE (Nordic International Leadership Education), LEAP (International LEAdership Programme of the German Olympic Sports Confederation - DOSB), and International Leadership Course of the Belgian Olympic and Interfederal Committee - BOIC workshop in Papendal, Netherlands. Bringing together emerging leaders from […]

Read More
SAFE HARBOUR showcased at Olympism365 Summit in Lausanne

From 3–5 June, the EOC EU Office took part in the Olympism365 Summit: Sport for a Better World, held in Lausanne. Bringing together leaders from the Olympic Movement, UN agencies, civil society and the private sector, the event focused on advancing the Sustainable Development Goals through sport, along with the theme of safeguarding in sport. […]

Read More

Related Posts

June 13, 2025
Monthly Report Highlight - European Parliament draft kicks off debate on a stronger, fairer European Sport Model

The debate on the future of the European Sport Model (ESM) entered a decisive phase this month with the publication of the draft report by the European Parliament’s Committee on Culture and Education (CULT). Authored by rapporteur Bogdan Andrzej Zdrojewski (EPP, PL), the text will serve as Parliament’s formal position before the European Commission prepares […]

June 6, 2025
Empowering future sport leaders in Papendal

This week, the EOC EU Office joined forces with its partner organisations engaged at the joint NILE (Nordic International Leadership Education), LEAP (International LEAdership Programme of the German Olympic Sports Confederation - DOSB), and International Leadership Course of the Belgian Olympic and Interfederal Committee - BOIC workshop in Papendal, Netherlands. Bringing together emerging leaders from […]

June 6, 2025
SAFE HARBOUR showcased at Olympism365 Summit in Lausanne

From 3–5 June, the EOC EU Office took part in the Olympism365 Summit: Sport for a Better World, held in Lausanne. Bringing together leaders from the Olympic Movement, UN agencies, civil society and the private sector, the event focused on advancing the Sustainable Development Goals through sport, along with the theme of safeguarding in sport. […]

About us

The EOC EU Office is the House of European Sport, representing the European Olympic Committees (EOC), the IOC and other major sport organisations to the European institutions in Brussels.
CONTACT
crossmenu linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram